Best Health Insurance Companies in West Virginia (2025 Guide)

 

Securing reliable health coverage in West Virginia depends on balancing cost, coverage, and service quality. Here is a look at the top insurance providers serving West Virginians, offering a full perspective on individual, marketplace, employer, and Medicare options.

🏆 1. Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield West Virginia

What makes Highmark stand out:

• Top-ranked overall for combining affordability, coverage, and customer service.

• Best Silver-tier premiums average around $737 per month.

• Offers both PPO and HMO options with extensive provider access—covering nearly two-thirds of marketplace members.

• Largest insurer in the state with broad hospital and doctor networks. 

Best for: Individuals and families seeking solid marketplace plans with flexible access and reliable support.

🥈 2. CareSource

Why it’s a strong contender:

• Known for offering HMO Silver plans with the lowest deductibles.

• Ideal for people wanting predictable costs at doctor's visits and prescriptions.

• Non-profit mission-driven provider, also offering Medicaid and Marketplace plans. 

Best for: Healthier individuals and families who prefer lower out-of-pocket costs and a straightforward network structure.

🥉 3. The Health Plan

Highlights:

• Offers Bronze-tier HMO and PPO plans with competitive pricing, such as expanded Bronze plans.

• Available statewide through the ACA marketplace. 

Best for: Individuals seeking affordable Bronze-level coverage with dependable provider access.

4. UnitedHealthcare & Aetna (Medicare and Employer Plans)

Why they matter:

• Strong Medicare Advantage offerings, rated highly in the state. Aetna, Highmark, and others offer top-tier senior plans. 

• Provide comprehensive employer and group plans with broad networks and virtual care options.

• Trusted brands with strong customer reputation.

Best for: Seniors and employees with employer-sponsored health plans.

5. Peak Health & Mountain Health Trust (Local Plans)

About Peak Health:

• Non-profit regional insurer tied to local health systems in Morgantown and beyond. Focuses on community-aligned, cost-conscious plans. 

Mountain Health Trust:

• Offers plans including HMO, PPO, and Medicaid through a local trust model. healthplan.org

Best for: Regional employers and members seeking a community-focused approach to health care.

📊 Quick Comparison Table

Provider	Best For	Highlights
Highmark BCBS WV	Broad access & cost-effective marketplace coverage	PPO/HMO options, extensive network
CareSource	Predictable costs, low deductibles	Mission-driven, good for families
The Health Plan	Affordable Bronze-tier marketplace coverage	Statewide HMO/PPO options
UnitedHealthcare & Aetna	Employer plans & strong Medicare Advantage options	Virtual care, wide networks
Peak Health & Mountain Health	Community-based and regional employer coverage	Local control, non-profit focus

✅ Choosing the Right Plan

1. Choose the right plan type – individual marketplace, employer-based, Medicaid, or Medicare.

2. Balance premium vs. deductible – choose a plan that suits your healthcare usage.

3. Check network coverage – ensure your preferred providers are included.

4. Look at plan features – such as prescription, mental health, and virtual care services.

5. Consider subsidies and employer contributions – many receive assistance that significantly lowers costs.

• Highmark BCBS shines for overall value, access, and service.

• CareSource delivers strong value for families who don’t need broad provider choice.

• The Health Plan offers budget-friendly Bronze options.

• UnitedHealthcare and Aetna serve well for employer and Medicare coverage.

• Peak Health and Mountain Health Trust offer valuable community-aligned plans.

Your ideal plan depends on your needs—evaluate coverage options, look at total costs, and choose based on both price and care quality.

Previous

Next